Showing posts with label Educational Theory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Educational Theory. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Heavy Reading

(cross-posted from Studeo)

I'm almost done with my second child psychology/parenting type book of the summer. They're both informational books designed for the masses, so they're relatively quick reads, but heavy nonetheless. Also scary in places, though helpful in many ways. I found them both to be quite worthwhile reads on the whole and hope to write up thorough reviews on Love2learn in the near future.

Incidentally, neither mentions homeschooling a bit, though they may end up providing a morale boost to homeschool parents both because they provide pretty broad coverage of some of the things schools struggle with and because they highlight some things children need (like time spent experiencing the world outside and plenty of time out-of-the-desk for younger children) that are easy and natural to accomplish at home. Both come from completely secular viewpoints.

Here are the titles:

Boys Adrift: The Five Factors Driving the Growing Epidemic of Unmotivated Boys and Underachieving Young Men by Leonard Sax

This book focuses on the problems - particularly in motivation - prevalent among teenage boys and young men today (especially as contrasted with 30 or 40 years ago). The author, a medical doctor AND psychologist, highlights five likely causes of the problem (changes within the school system, video games, ADHD medications, environmental factors and cultural problems (especially the lack of role models). To be fair, this list over-simplifies factors that he treats in a pretty balanced way. For example, he doesn't insist that video games should be entirely avoided, but advocates reasonable time limits parental screening of individual games to avoid dangerously violent and inappropriate ones.

I did find the book alarming in a number of places, partly because his tone is a bit sensational in places (although there are probably many people who could use such a wake-up call). Keeping the skeptometer in tune while reading the book is a good idea, but there's really a lot of helpful stuff to dig through here.

and

NurtureShock: New Thinking About Children by Po Bronson and Ashley Merryman

This book focuses on a number of issues relating to parenting and education in which science shows us a different view from current cultural assumptions. As someone who's a convention breaker both by circumstances and personality, I found this book, for the most part, quite delightful. While the previous book is based on one doctor's experiences and interactions, but with a lot of scientific data for back-up, this book is a denser conglomeration of scientific studies on different topics which the authors have gotten heavily involved in. I loved how often they had actually sat down and observed studies conducted by experts in various micro-fields of child behavior while still sharing interesting stories about how their new-found knowledge had impacted their own families. Lots of cool stuff!

Like the previous book, however, there were certainly a few things here and there that bothered me or set off my skeptometer (not so much regarding the scientific data as the commentary surrounding it). Also, younger moms who tend towards the paranoid might want to discuss the details with friends and family enough to help them avoid over-analyzing their own methods. The book isn't about some sort of perfectionist parenting technique, but more about eliminating (or at least casting some doubt upon) ideas that tend to be counterproductive.

Thursday, April 16, 2009

Catholic Liberal Education Retreat

Many parents who get into home schooling find a strong emphasis on a classical, Catholic liberal education. Not having had one themselves, they find it hard to implement one for their own children, especially high school. Books like Laura Berquist's Designing Your Own Classical Curriculum help, but nothing beats participating in a truly liberal education.

To that end I'd like to suggest the Academic Retreat for Teachers (July 12-17, Fr. Wayne, Indiana) put on the the Institute for Catholic Liberal Education, whose president is Dr. Andrew Seeley, of Thomas Aquinas College. I have been on this retreat (as a presenter), and I can tell you, the participants are immerced in a genuine culture of Catholic liberal education, with an emphasis on the trivium and quadrivium, literature and religion. You can't help but "get it" after this experience. The cost is reasonable, $450, considering what you get out of it. Of course, the closer you live to Indiana, the more convenient the travel is. The campus of St. Francis is very warm and refreshing and the building in which much of the retreat is held is an old, beautifully appointed, stately Victorian mansion.

Here is their blurb:

The Institute for Catholic Liberal EducationInvites You to its 2009
Academic Retreat for Teachers
“Truth and Joy in the Catholic School”

IMAGINE a week of uninterrupted time to:

  • Explore the foundations of Catholic education with colleagues from around the country
  • Discuss the history and integration of Western education, the Trivium, Mathematics, Science, Literature, Theology and Music, Read and discuss authors such as Newman, Dawson, Shakespeare, Euclid, John Paul II and more
  • Discuss these writings with an intimate group of peers
  • Refresh and revitalize your sense of wonder and joy of learning!

THIS is truly an Academic Retreatlike none other...

REGISTER AND PAY ONLINE NOW!!!

Register and Pay by Check Now!

DATE: July 12-17
LOCATION: University of St. Francis - Fort Wayne, Indiana
COST:EARLY BIRD (by June 1): Registration Only $450
AFTER June 1: $495Includes room, board and materials
Questions? Call 805/625-1817

"What made this experience unique was that we did more than simply talk about the merits of a classical curriculum, we experienced them for ourselves, first hand.... I am writing to thank you for putting together a wonderful and carefully thoughtout conference. It provided a much-needed respite from the stress and chaos of becoming assistant principal at a new high school."—Peter Fletcher, Assistant Principal, St. Michael the Archangel, Baton Rouge, LA

To sign register online, click here, or write to:Summer Academic RetreatsInstitute for Catholic Liberal EducationPO Box 4638Ventura, CA 93007

Monday, October 29, 2007

Education and Discipline

On the FOX news website is this very interesting interview of Dr. Bernhard Bueb by Fr. Jonathan Morris.

Dr. Bueb is headmaster of one of Germany's most prestigious boarding schools, and he calls for a return to discipline in schools as a necessity for proper education.

This interview is more than just another article on schools -- he has many insights that echo 20th century Popes.

Thursday, May 24, 2007

"What is Classical" by Mary Daly

The word "classical" has perhaps seven meanings. It is natural for a word to undergo certain kinds of shifts in meaning, each one an extension of the earlier one, but it is important to state exactly which meaning is operative in a particular discussion.

1) Upper class. Classical seems originally to have meant upper class, as opposed to proletarian, which is low class.

2) Greek and Roman. And what do the upper classes do that the proletarians do not? They go to school and are able to study the foundations of Western culture, the writings of the Greeks and Romans. So Classical means the study of Greek and Roman writings, only the best of course (see def 1). And the "Classical languages" are Greek and Latin. Protestant classicists are more likely to study Greek; Catholics, Latin. Families engaged in classical education often teach the Greek and Roman myths at an early age (see below).

3) The foundation and model of Western culture. Having studied the Greeks and Romans, other ancient authors produced wonderful works. Even aside from these, from a Christian perspective, the Bible (though originally Hebrew) and the Church Fathers are classical, not only because these documents come to us in Greek and Latin, but even more because they are the substantial foundation of Western culture. St. Augustine's Confessions is a classic work. And St. Thomas Aquinas himself, at the height of scholasticism, which means the Schools (see definition one) was a Latin writer whose works are foundational in Catholic theology.

3 a) Foundation and model. For that matter, we may consider that there are other cultures. The great Hindu "classic" is the Baghavad Gita. It was originally Sanskrit, and is the foundation of Hinduism. Sanskrit, like Latin, is a language no longer spoken. It is the classical language of India. Similarly, the writings of Confucius are Chinese classics. Cultures without writing cannot have classical authors, of course.

4) Characterized by clarity, reason, balance, harmony, and symmetry; free of overwhelming emotion. The Greek ideal of beauty has nothing wild in it, though in fact there were highly unbalanced, Dionysian elements in Greek culture. Still, any work of art that has these characteristics of reason and harmony may be called classical. Especially when we speak of music, we never mean Greek music. We mean Bach, Beethoven, and Mozart and whoever fits with their measured ideals. We do not mean Wagner, in whose works intensity of feeling is the overwhelms characteristic.

Note: families with a classical curriculum often teach the Greek and Roman myths. Some of these myths are pretty violent and wild. Are they appropriate to small children? They fit definition 2, but not this definition of classical; yet many other classical works refer to them, so that at some point you need the information as a point of reference. Milo Winter's classic presentation (old, back in print; see definitions #5 and #6 below) is fairly charming and may encourage children to think about meanings and values without too much wildness or despair.

5) Old, having withstood the test of time. Of course the foundations of any culture will be old, compared to the general culture. The Greek and Roman writings are old. And it often happens that what is old becomes lost unless somebody thinks it worthwhile, year after year. So classical comes to mean old, and having withstood the test of time. Still, every generation has its share of fools, and this definition of classical may include things that are arguably not very valuable. It is the weakest definition. By this definition, Wagner's work is a musical classic. The I Ching is a very old Chinese work which many people value. It is, however, Gnostic, compared to Confucius. It refers, not to reason and balance, but to unverifiable interiorities with a flavor of snobbery for those who attend to them. Is it a classic? What is your definition? It is old and lots of people have read it and been influenced by it. It doesn't fit definitions #1 to 4.

6) Model, standard. This use of the word classic will appear in clothing catalogs. Certain styles have been accepted so long and so fully that they are the standard by which others are naturally judged. Classic Coke follows this definition. It is the standard against which all other soft drinks are implicitly compared, even 7-Up, the "uncola". Again, Greek and Roman works are the standard of literature - but so is Shakespeare, who has handily survived his contemporaries' criticism that he was uneducated (in the university approach to Greek and Roman classics.) Classical education sometimes refers to an education that is careful to look beyond fads to what has endured.

7) Excellent, the best, of perennial value. What is the use of limiting one's education to what is old? Surely if one is educated, one should be able to recognize what is the best right now, even if it is new. Would you not be ashamed to think you might have lived in the time of Shakespeare and refused to let your students attend the Globe theater merely because it was contemporary? If we have understood the earlier definitions, we will be alert to the modern classics, recognizing or at least trying to recognize what is excellent and what is of lasting value in our culture right now. I would assert that Tolkein is a classic in this sense. Being an English work, less than 60 years on the open market, he cannot fit any of the above definitions except #5, but he is excellent by all the standards that make it worthwhile to study the Greeks, the Romans, and the Bible, long after the (human) authors of those works have died. His work is rich in wisdom and culture, linguistically beautiful, thoughtful. It will outlive everything else on the open market today.

What should be considered by Catholic homeschoolers? I think we should have an eye on the entire progression, which is a natural linguistic development, and on all the materials which are foundational or excellent -- or both -- within the culture which developed from Greece, Rome, and Israel right up to 21st century Catholicism.

April 26, 2001

Tuesday, May 08, 2007

The Institute for Catholic Liberal Education - Academic Retreat for Teachers

  • Discuss the profound and practical reflections of great thinkers on education

  • Learn with like-minded colleagues in an atmosphere of reflection and devotion

  • Return to your classroom with a renewed joy in learning and practical suggestions to share with your academic community


Monday: Christopher Dawson and the History of Western Education
Tuesday: Sr. Miriam Joseph and The Trivium
Wednesday: Euclid, Descartes and the Quadrivium
Thursday: Newton, Democritus and Science
Friday: “Wisdom” Subjects: Literature with Newman, History with Dawson, Theology with JP II

Plus: Seminars on Sophocles and Shakespeare, Lectures on Poetry and Music

Read more here

Tuesday, April 10, 2007

The Aim of All Christian Education

I'm finishing up reading the second part of Sacramentum Caritatis for our teen discussion tonight. I'm glad we decided to meet during Holy Week and Easter Week as the readings and discussions have been conducive to a better understanding and appreciation of the Easter Triduum celebrations.

Here's a short, but meaty quote from today's reading:
The aim of all Christian education, moreover, is to train the believer in an adult faith that can make him a "new creation", capable of bearing witness in his surroundings to the Christian hope that inspires him.
The Holy Father is speaking here in the context of religious education in preparation for the sacraments, but I think he's also pointing to a larger sense of the meaning and purpose of education.

Sunday, March 25, 2007

Announcing: Love2learn Moments on Catholic Radio

After many months of uncertainty, I've been told by people-who-should know that my "Love2learn Moments" - one minute spots on Relevant Radio on topics relating to family life and education (especially for homeschoolers, though many topics would apply more broadly) - will begin airing tomorrow. I don't know a lot about how these things work, but I believe this is starting out just in the Milwaukee area market. Each "moment" will air four times a day for a week before switching to a new one. I believe that if you have Relevant Radio in your area, you can contact them to request this piece. Prayers are appreciated as we fully embrace this new endeavour. You can visit the Love2learn Moments blog here.

Monday, January 29, 2007

Pope Benedict XVI on Beauty in Education

MESSAGE OF THE HOLY FATHER BENEDICT XVI FOR THE 41st WORLD COMMUNICATIONS DAY

Theme: "Children and the Media: A Challenge for Education"

Children exposed to what is aesthetically and morally excellent are helped to develop appreciation, prudence and the skills of discernment. Here it is important to recognize the fundamental value of parents’ example and the benefits of introducing young people to children's classics in literature, to the fine arts and to uplifting music. While popular literature will always have its place in culture, the temptation to sensationalize should not be passively accepted in places of learning. Beauty, a kind of mirror of the divine, inspires and vivifies young hearts and minds, while ugliness and coarseness have a depressing impact on attitudes and behaviour.

Read the entire text here

hat-tip Cause of our Joy

Tuesday, January 16, 2007

Accidental vs. On-Purpose Learning

I think Lissa's post at The Lilting House on "Accidental v. On-Purpose Learning" makes some very helpful distinctions in considering different types of school subjects and weighing different learning priorities.
Where I connect with unschooling is in the understanding that people (of all ages) learn best when they WANT to learn, are interested in the subject, feel joy in the process, and that standard classroom educational methods are not necessarily (or even usually) the best ways to learn. Children have such an eager appetite for knowledge (it is, as Miss Mason says, the food their minds are made to live on) that it is not, in my opinion, at all necessary to turn the experience of gaining knowledge into a drudgery, conflict, or carrot-and-stick experience.

Where I depart from unschooling is in my understanding that adults have a wider perspective than children, are (it is to be hoped) wiser than children, and that this is quite natural and proper. And just as my parental wisdom and experience directs me to provide a nutritious diet for my children, so does it direct me to provide a rich and nourishing menu of ideas and learning experiences for their growing minds.

Read the entire post.

Monday, October 09, 2006

New Report: Kids Need More Play, Less Structured Time

Read the report from the American Academy of Pediatrics here.

Nice to see some balance being promoted.

UPDATE: I just noticed that, Danielle Bean is hosting a discussion on this very topic here.

Vatican Releases Regensberg Talk

The Vatican has released the offical translation of the Pope's talk at Regensberg, complete with footnotes.

Hat-tip Amy Welborn

Thursday, July 27, 2006

Cardinal Newman on Formation of the Intellect

...one main portion of intellectual education, of the labours of both school and university, is to remove the original dimness of the mind's eye; to strengthen and perfect its vision; to enable it to look out into the world right forward, steadily and truly; to give the mind clearness, accuracy, precision; to enable it to use words aright, to understand what it says, to conceive justly what it thinks about, to abstract, compare, analyze, divide, define, and reason, correctly. There is a particular science which takes these matters in hand, and it is called logic; but it is not by logic, certainly not by logic alone, that the faculty I speak of is acquired. The infant does not learn to spell and read the hues upon his retina by any scientific rule; nor does the student learn accuracy of thought by any manual or treatise. The instruction given him, of whatever kind, if it be really instruction, is mainly, or at least pre-eminently, this - a discipline in accuracy of mind.


His maxim is "a little, but well"; that is, really know what you say you know: know what you know and what you do not know; get one thing well before you go on to a second; try to ascertain what your words mean; when you read a sentence, picture it before your mind as a whole, take in the truth or information contained in it, express it in your own words, and, if it be important, commit it to faithful memory. Again, compare one idea with another; adjust truths and facts; form them into one whole, or notice the obstacles which occur in doing so. This is the way to make progress; this is the way to arrive at results; not to swallow knowledge, but (according to the figure sometimes used) to masticate and digest it.



...both quotes are from The Idea of a University, from "Elementary Studies"

Tuesday, June 06, 2006

Still on Chesterton

Returning from the Catholic Homeschool Conference in Minneapolis, I am happy to report that the Friday night session treated attendants with a visit from Chesterton himself.

At least he looked like Chesterton, talked and moved around like Chesterton: for one hour he simply delighted his audience with excerpts and quotes from the beloved Catholic author on life, marriage, women, paradoxes of life and the list goes on.

The presentation was done by Dr. John Chalberg, who also goes around the country doing impersonations of several other historical characters. Dr. Chalberg had a booth at the conference and was available for a nice chat at any time. Check his website for booking information and more.

My parents had Chesterton volumes in Portuguese on the shelves, and I remember feeble attempts on my part, perhaps at the wrong time, to tackle the author. It never happened. This presentation Friday evening has special meaning to me: having resisted reading Chesterton for years, I knew sitting through may cost me something—and I was correct in thinking so. At the end of the presentation, and I commented this with him afterwards, I was curious and interested in the writings of Chesterton enough to look around the vending area for a book that would introduce Chesterton to my literature files. I purchased Ignatius Press’ Brave New Family: G. K. Chesterton on Men and Women, Children, Sex, Divorce, Marriage and the Family, edited by Alvaro da Silva. About the book, from Ignatius Press website:

A collection of G. K. Chesterton's provocative writings on a subject close to his heart--the family, and the corresponding themes of men and women, children, sex, marriage and divorce. The family was a central element in Chesterton's vision, a unifying theme of his literary work. His eloquent defense of the sacredness of the home is even more applicable in our times because of the tremendous moral problems in our society that threaten the modern family.

"This is one of those absolutely necessary books. No one had such bracing no-nonsense practical wisdom as Chesterton. Now this book brings together the embattled family and GKC, the knight who rides forth to do battle for it. It should serve as a manual for us to turn the tide and restore ancient sanities."

-- Peter Kreeft, Author, Three Philosophies of Life

"There is something providential in the way G. K. Chesterton has returned to speak to us of great realities that matter. With prophetic insight he meets the threats to the family, which have increased so much since his era. This book is essential reading, not only for all who work to build up family life but for those who want to rediscover the treasure hidden in that small word which Chesterton loved--"home".

-- Cardinal Edouard Gagnon, Pontifical Council for the Family

"The consecrated pen of Chesterton exposed the attack on the family by a tangle of theorists years before our present social calamity. He shatters their fatal nonsense with the splendor of Christian personalism."

-- Fr. George Rutler, Author, Beyond Modernity

Saturday, May 13, 2006

Wow!

"One is entitled to think that the future of humanity is in the hands of those who are capable of providing the generations to come with reasons for life and optimism." (Gaudium et Spes as quoted in the Catechism of the Catholic Church 1917)

Tuesday, May 09, 2006

A Star is Made

I thought this article from the New York Times on techniques of learning was interesting and worthwhile, particularly the following:

~ The concept of "deliberate practice" (defined in the article as "setting specific goals, obtaining immediate feedback and concentrating as much on technique as on outcome")

~ The importance of doing something you love for a career

~ The concept from which the title comes - that limitations based on genetics are probably less significant than we tend to think .

Saturday, May 06, 2006

An Atmosphere of Love and Learning

Melissa Wiley has a great post on atmosphere in the home which includes a reminder of great examples of family life found in children's books. I've often thought that these sort of books (Little House, Hilda Van Stockum's Mitchell's Series, etc.) can be as important (or even better) than many parenting books to inspire a beautiful family life.